2016
Claire Green - U Indy (D2)
Regina Doty - Ohio State (D1)
2017
Kenzie Bemis - McKendree (D2)
Mary Grace Cusumano - DePauw (D3)
Kate Daniels - U Indy (D2)
Natalie DeWitt - Yale (D1)
Sarah Hardin - McKendree (D2)
Cierra Kelley - Embry Riddel (D2)
Erin Rauber - Benedictine (D2)
Katie Woodruff - Davidson (D1)
2018
Clara Andrews - McKendree (D2)
Rebecca Cappaert - Marquette (D1)
Haley Downs - Marville (D2)
Claudette Roskamp - Earlham (D3)
Jennifer Williams - Vermont (D1)
2019
Madi Reisig - Oklahoma Baptist (D2)
Lauren Youngquist - Colorado at Colorado Springs (D2)
Alex McWhirter - Depauw University (D2)
Anna Reynolds - Grand Valley State University (D2)
Sydney Tiemann - McKendree University (D2)
2020
Brooke Lierman - Florida Southern College (D2)
Chloe Weaver- Rockhurst University (D2)
Addie Bellistri - Ohio Northern University (D3)
2021
Addie Bitting - Indianapolis University (D2)
Grace Hensley - Butler University (D1)
Sophia Scheller - McKendree University (D2)
Ruth Vogel - Rockhurst University (D2)
